diff --git a/ts/components/StoriesSettingsModal.tsx b/ts/components/StoriesSettingsModal.tsx
index 7ca3a4ac50..2e98fd3e5b 100644
--- a/ts/components/StoriesSettingsModal.tsx
+++ b/ts/components/StoriesSettingsModal.tsx
@@ -840,7 +840,7 @@ export function EditMyStoryPrivacy({
       {hasDisclaimerAbove && disclaimerElement}
 
       <Checkbox
-        checked={!myStories.members.length}
+        checked={myStories.isBlockList && !myStories.members.length}
         isRadio
         label={i18n('StoriesSettings__mine__all--label')}
         moduleClassName="StoriesSettingsModal__checkbox"